India need to choose between Pant & Karthik: Karim

Dinsh Karthik and Rishabh Pant
Dinsh Karthik and Rishabh Pant are fighting for a palce in the playing eleven. File photo: AFP/Chandan Khanna

New Delhi: Former Indian wicketkeeper-batter Saba Karim feels that the side has to decide between keeping either Rishabh Pant or Dinesh Karthik in the playing eleven.

With the Asia Cup starting from August 27 in the UAE, the tournament presents a chance for India to sort out their playing eleven ahead of T20 World Cup in Australia in October-November. Since his comeback to T20I cricket in June, Karthik has been bringing out the required finishing acts and effectively sealing the finisher's spot in the Indian team.

A 27-ball 55 on a tough pitch against South Africa at Rajkot and an unbeaten 19-ball 41 on a tricky wicket against the West Indies at Trinidad have been couple of examples of Karthik's finishing role benefitting Team India in recent times.

On the other hand, Pant has had a mixed run apart from being tried as an opener twice against England. Since the T20I series against South Africa in June, where he was the stand-in skipper, Pant's highest score has been 44 in fourth T20I against the West Indies at Lauderhill, USA.

"I feel that to get the balance right, India has done well with five bowlers plus Hardik Pandya as a sixth bowling option. So would you like to break that kind of a combination and get in another bat at No. 7 that is Dinesh Karthik at No. 7? That means that you go in with Hardik Pandya (as) the fifth bowler who is expected to bowl four overs, so that is another big call from the Indian team management."

"So then if so that that may pose some issues for the Indian team management. Whatever I have seen from Rohit Sharma's captaincy, I think he prefers to have five regular bowlers plus Hardik Pandya as their six bowling option. If that is the case then you need to decide between Rishabh Pant and Dinesh Karthik," said Karim on 'Sports Over The Top' show on Sports18.

Karim added that deciding between keeping Pant or Karthik in the eleven will help in India sorting the No. 4 spot in T20Is. "Yes, you better need to sort it out as soon as possible. But you know what, to fix the No. 4 slot or the No. 4 position for specific player, we need to get the combination and balance of the side correct."

"When I say this I mean they need to pick between Dinesh Kartik or Rishabh Pant. Once you decide on either of these player, it'll get easy to sort in Suryakumar Yadav at No. 4."

Karim further picked Suryakumar, Pandya and Pant to be his ideal batters at four, five and six while K L Rahul is his choice to open the batting alongside Rohit Sharma. Rahul has been out of competitive cricketing action since featuring in the IPL 2022 Eliminator on May 25 in Kolkata.

Rahul was then named as captain for the five-match T20I series at home against South Africa in June. But a right groin injury on the eve of the first match in New Delhi ruled him out of the series. The sports hernia surgery in Germany meant that Rahul was ruled out of England tour too.

He was set to return during India's T20I series against the West Indies, but a positive COVID-19 test ahead of the tour meant he wasn't included in trip to the Caribbean.

"KL Rahul being the vice-captain, I look at him as an opener with Rohit Sharma. I look at Virat Kohli at No. 3 and Suryakumar Yadav at No. 4. But you know what, 4,5,6 has to be very flexible kind of a position because in a T20 format, you look at 4,5,6 who can finish games for you and can also double up as a power hitter when required, can also stabilise the innings."

"Those three batters at 4,5,6, my choice would be Suryakumar Yadav, Hardik Pandya and Rishabh Pant. And you can move them around depending on the number of overs you're left with. But K L Rahul in my opinion, should bat up the order with Rohit Sharma," concluded Karim.

The comments posted here/below/in the given space are not on behalf of Onmanorama. The person posting the comment will be in sole ownership of its responsibility. According to the central government's IT rules, obscene or offensive statement made against a person, religion, community or nation is a punishable offense, and legal action would be taken against people who indulge in such activities.